The Risks of Mishandling Tenant Deposits: Why Landlords Should Leave It to the Experts

The Risks of Mishandling Tenant Deposits: Why Landlords Should Leave It to the Experts

As a landlord, registering and protecting your tenant’s deposit might seem like a straightforward task — but in reality, there’s a lot that can go wrong if it isn’t done correctly. From missed deadlines to incorrect dispute handling, failing to follow the right procedures can lead to serious legal and financial consequences.

At Bates & Co, based in Hailsham, covering Eastbourne, Polegate, Stonecross, Bexhill and surrounding areas, we take care of this process from start to finish — ensuring your compliance, avoiding costly mistakes, and giving you complete peace of mind.

Landlord Deposit Responsibilities: What the Law Requires

In England, the law states that if you rent out a property on an Assured Shorthold Tenancy (AST), any deposit taken from the tenant must be:

1. Protected in a government-approved tenancy deposit scheme (TDP) within 30 calendar days of receipt
2. Prescribed Information must be served to the tenant within the same 30-day window
3. The deposit must be returned in full at the end of the tenancy unless deductions are properly agreed and justified

Approved deposit protection schemes include:

• Deposit Protection Service (DPS)
• MyDeposits
• Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS)

What Can Go Wrong If You Handle It Yourself?

Too many landlords make small but critical mistakes that result in large penalties or legal challenges. Common issues include:

• Missing the 30-day deadline for registering the deposit
• Failing to issue the prescribed information to the tenant‍
• Using the wrong scheme or not protecting the full deposit
• Not keeping proper records of registration or deductions‍
• Poor handling of end-of-tenancy disputes or not following correct adjudication processes

Even if the tenancy ends smoothly, if the deposit was not correctly registered, a tenant can legally claim compensation of up to three times the deposit amount. This is a risk no landlord should take.

The Dispute Process – And Why You Need to Get It Right

At the end of a tenancy, if there are disagreements about deductions for cleaning, damage, rent arrears or other issues, disputes are resolved via the deposit scheme’s Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) service.

However, this process requires:

• Clear evidence (photos, inventories, invoices)
• Adherence to strict timeframes
• A strong understanding of what counts as “fair wear and tear” vs. tenant damage

Many landlords lose disputes simply because they lack proper documentation or mismanage communications with the tenant or scheme.

How Bates & Co Protects You

At Bates & Co, we take care of every step of the deposit registration and management process to keep you legally protected:

We register deposits on time with a government-approved scheme
We issue the correct Prescribed Information to tenants within legal timeframes
We provide detailed inventories and check-in/check-out reports to support any future deductions
We handle all end-of-tenancy communication with tenants
If disputes arise, we compile and submit evidence for you
You stay 100% compliant — avoiding fines, legal challenges, or disputes

Why Risk It?

Landlords who self-manage deposits often don’t realise how quickly things can unravel. A missed deadline or wrong form can turn into a court case and thousands in fines. Worse still, mishandling a deposit can weaken your position in Section 21 evictions, meaning you might not even be able to regain possession of your property when needed.

That’s why more landlords in Hailsham, Eastbourne, and surrounding areas are choosing to let Bates & Co handle it all. We’ve seen it all before — and we know how to do it right, every time.

Let Bates & Co Handle It

Whether you're a new landlord or someone managing multiple properties, the deposit process is not something to take lightly. We offer full management services that ensure your rental business stays compliant, professional, and profitable.

📍 Serving Hailsham, Eastbourne, Polegate, and surrounding areas
📞 Get in touch today for expert advice or a free Property Compliance Check

‍